Sexual abuse of children is one of the most heartbreaking issues any family can face. When that abuse happens on a military base daycare run by trusted officials, the sense of shock and betrayal grows even stronger. This was the reality for several Marine Corps families whose young children attended the Child Development Center (CDC) at Marine Corps Air Station (MCAS) Yuma in Arizona. Between December 2020 and March 2021, these parents say, toddlers as young as 1 or 2 years old experienced repeated neglect and mistreatment at the hands of caregivers.
Now, five of these families have filed lawsuits against the federal government, claiming that negligent hiring practices, insufficient supervision, and an overall lack of proper oversight allowed abuse to thrive. They allege that the CDC’s leadership failed in its core responsibility to provide a safe environment for children.
Some caregivers have already been convicted in county court, but for the survivors and their families, the responsibility goes deeper than just a couple of rogue staff members. The core issue is institutional liability—holding the military facility and its managers accountable for their systemic failures.
You are not alone. We stand with you to seek justice and accountability.
Why Are Marine Corps Families Filing Lawsuits?
When families discovered that their toddlers had suffered abuse at the MCAS Yuma CDC, their first concern was their children’s immediate safety. They also turned to base officials and law enforcement for protection and answers. After investigating, it came to light that multiple caregivers were implicated in repeated incidents of physical harm, including forcefully placing children in chairs, shoving them into tables, and making them hit themselves with their own hands.
Although a couple of caregivers faced criminal charges, the families realized the bigger issue: a series of bad decisions and ignored complaints that allowed the abuse to continue over a three-month stretch. The lawsuit claims these neglectful conditions were rooted in poor hiring standards, inadequate training, and a reluctance to hold staff accountable, even after multiple red flags. Instead of just confronting individual wrongdoers, the parents are also targeting the larger system, which they believe played a direct role in letting the abuse happen.
The damages they’re seeking range from $900,000 to $5 million for each family. While money won’t erase the trauma, these amounts can cover extensive therapy, medical treatment, and other support services the children may need for years to come. They also send a message that the government and the military must do far better at supervising those entrusted with child care.
How Did the Abuse at MCAS Yuma Allegedly Occur?
Based on the lawsuits and subsequent media coverage, the alleged abuse targeted toddlers between 1 and 2 years old at the base’s CDC. Families say these children were subjected to alarming acts like being forced to sit in chairs by force, shoved into tables, or even hit with toys. In some cases, staff allegedly carried children by just an arm or leg, ignoring cries of pain. Police reports identified more than 200 cases of abuse during a short three-month window, and about 15 children were said to be affected.
Video surveillance at the daycare, which was only kept for 90 days, revealed hundreds of incidents—suggesting that this wasn’t a one-time event but a chronic problem. Two caregivers named in the lawsuits have already been convicted in Yuma County court. Another caregiver, named in documents, did not face charges but is still mentioned in the allegations. The families argue that if the base had thorough oversight—like consistently reviewing security camera footage or investigating complaints more aggressively—these horrors might have been stopped earlier, protecting the kids from ongoing harm.
Why Sue the Government Rather Than Just the Caregivers?
Often, individuals don’t have the financial resources to compensate families for therapy, medical bills, or the lasting emotional impact caused by abuse. Institutions, on the other hand, usually carry insurance and have deeper pockets.
More importantly, these cases aim to expose and change the environment that allowed wrongdoing to occur. If a daycare or base leadership failed to conduct background checks, ignored prior complaints about staff conduct, or neglected thorough staff training, that negligence may make them legally accountable under institutional liability.
In the MCAS Yuma situation, the lawsuits focus on the daycare’s alleged failures in screening caregivers, supervising them, and reacting to potential red flags. If families can prove the Marine Corps Air Station’s leadership knew—or should have known—about these dangers and chose not to address them, they have a strong argument that the institution shares blame. By holding the government responsible, survivors can get compensation and force reforms, ensuring future caregivers are better trained and supervised.
How Is Child Abuse Typically Handled on Military Bases?
Military bases, like any community, run daycare centers for service members’ children. These centers should meet both federal regulations and the specific guidelines of each military branch. Normally, this means thorough background checks, staff training, and regular inspections. However, each base’s level of rigor can vary.
In MCAS Yuma’s case, the families argue that base leadership did not uphold these expected standards. If they had, the frequent incidents of forceful handling and physical harm might have been noticed and addressed sooner. Some parents question whether the transitory nature of military bases—where staff and families come and go—made it easier for repeated problems to slip through the cracks.
It’s important to note that the Marine Corps says they fully cooperated with authorities and they’ve taken measures like installing closed-circuit TV monitoring. However, from the families’ perspective, these steps either came too late or were never enforced vigorously enough to prevent the harm that occurred.
What Are the Legal Implications of Filing a Federal Lawsuit?
Suing the federal government or its agencies typically involves special rules, such as the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA). This law allows private citizens to file claims against the U.S. government for certain wrongs, including negligence. However, the process can be more complicated than a typical lawsuit. Families must follow strict timelines, file administrative claims first, and wait for the government’s response. Only then can they proceed to court if the government rejects or doesn’t settle the claim.
In these MCAS Yuma cases, five families have collectively taken this step, citing the base’s negligence as a federal liability. A child abuse lawyer experienced in FTCA cases can help navigate deadlines, gather necessary documentation, and present a compelling argument about how the government’s own policies or staff actions led to these tragedies. While these suits might take time, the potential results include monetary awards that can fund therapy and medical care, and push for systemic change.
How Are Caregivers Being Held Accountable?
Two caregivers—Valerie McKinstry and Katherine McCombs—have already been convicted in Yuma County court. McKinstry served nearly two weeks in jail plus probation, and McCombs received probation. A third caregiver was named in legal documents but did not face criminal charges. For some families, these relatively light sentences seem insufficient, especially compared to the lasting damage their children endured.
However, the families’ bigger concern is that the daycare’s overall structure allowed these caregivers to behave abusively—possibly for months—without leadership stepping in. The base’s formal statement emphasizes that children’s well-being is their top priority, but this sentiment rings hollow for those who watched their toddlers suffer harm. The lawsuits, therefore, aim higher, not just punishing the individual caregivers but also holding Marine Corps officials liable if they neglected early warnings or let incompetent employees stay on.
Are the Children Recovering from the Abuse?
Reports indicate that many of the toddlers developed physical and emotional difficulties after the alleged abuse. Some show delayed emotional development, while others exhibit self-harm behaviors or lingering anxieties. One child referred to as A.H. was allegedly assaulted at least 110 times within a 90-day window and now has permanent behavioral issues and developmental delays. Another child might be fearful of certain activities or places that trigger traumatic memories.
Parents say the children continue to need specialized therapy and possibly medical interventions. Their lawsuits include these ongoing costs—like therapy, special education services, and potential future treatment. This emotional toll highlights why compensation is so important. It’s not about a financial windfall; it’s about covering the real expenses and life disruptions caused by the daycare’s alleged failures.
How Does a Child Abuse Lawyer Help in Such Cases?
A child abuse lawyer typically begins by investigating the facts: they gather incident reports, medical records, staff rosters, and any prior complaints lodged with the daycare. They might depose base officials or collect testimony from teachers, counselors, or anyone who witnessed suspicious behavior. The goal is to show a pattern of negligence or refusal to act on warning signs.
Additionally, attorneys help families navigate complex federal or state statutes, which can be daunting. Because these daycares are run by or on behalf of the military, special rules and deadlines may apply. Lawyers skilled in these matters also handle communications with the government’s legal team, shielding families from aggressive questioning or intimidation tactics.
Finally, child abuse attorneys stand by the survivors emotionally. Revisiting traumatic events can be painful. Good lawyers ensure families understand each step, from the initial filing to settlement offers or trial strategies. They also connect them to mental health resources, emphasizing that, beyond money, the legal process can provide a sense of acknowledgment that the child’s suffering is recognized and validated.
What If the Military Base Denies Wrongdoing?
It’s not unusual for large institutions, including military bases, to initially deny liability. They might claim the abuse was an isolated incident by a couple of “bad apples,” not evidence of a broader lapse in leadership. Or they might dispute the severity of the survivors’ injuries. This is where having thorough, well-documented evidence is critical.
Through discovery—the legal procedure that compels sharing of documents and information—child abuse attorneys can demand logs from the daycare, staff meeting minutes, or even internal emails about how complaints were handled. If the base refuses to comply or attempts to stall, judges can impose penalties. So, even if the institution denies wrongdoing at first, the legal process can force it to reveal any internal knowledge that might contradict those denials.
Should the evidence show repeated ignoring of staff misconduct or instructing people to keep quiet, it would significantly strengthen the families’ claims. Sometimes, institutions opt to settle out of court once they see the weight of evidence. If they remain steadfast in denial, the matter may go to trial, where a jury or judge determines the outcome.
A Qualified Child Abuse Lawyer Can Clarify Your Rights, Call Today
The lawsuits brought by Marine Corps families against the government over child abuse at the MCAS Yuma daycare shine a stark light on the concept of institutional liability. By alleging that negligent hiring, weak training, and poor supervision created an environment where repeated abuse of toddlers can occur, they challenge the base’s leadership to acknowledge—and remedy—systemic failings. In a sense, these families are not just seeking monetary compensation; they’re pushing for real reform to ensure no other child endures such trauma under military childcare.
If you believe a similar situation has happened in your child’s life—whether in a daycare, school, sports league, or religious institution—know that you have options. Investigating institutional negligence can be a difficult endeavor, but a qualified child abuse lawyer can help gather evidence, overcome legal hurdles, and negotiate or litigate for a just outcome. Holding the organization accountable goes beyond any single staff member’s wrongdoing; it prompts changes that keep future children safe.
Take that important first step by reaching out to a child abuse lawyer for a free consultation. Even if you’re uncertain or feel overwhelmed, talking to a qualified child abuse attorney can clarify your legal rights and possible next steps. By hiring a legal ally, you can trust that your case will be handled with the utmost care and professionalism
Your courage in standing up for your child’s well-being can lead to both compensation for the harms endured and systemic improvements that benefit countless other families. Reach out now to learn about the next steps.